Caffeine Up Your Life
Professor Moore of the University of Illinois
Urbana-Champaign, told us to explore the sciences of our everyday life. So, as
I was recounting in my head what I do on a daily basis, I naturally got
distracted by my facebook. As I was browsing through it, one of the
posts on my home page was about coffee, because I “like” caffeine as a part of
my facebook account. Then I came across the realization, that I consume large
amounts of caffeine on a daily basis. My father always drank coffee growing up
and so did both of my grandfathers, so to me, drinking coffee was a natural
progression. Coffee has helped me out in a variety of ways throughout my life
and since I am an athlete sometimes a burst of caffeine can really mean the difference
in work outs and during races. But I never really knew why or how caffeine
supplements give such high bursts of energy until I started doing some research
about the topic. In the post they talked about how caffeine can improve
exercise performance and that it increases your heart rate. Their study focused
on twelve well-trained and familiarized male cyclists, who were caffeine
consumers. This sparked my interest, but I felt like more information was out
there to explore that would help me better understand the effects of caffeine.
What does it mean to “significantly improve exercise performance” and how did
they record work out efficiency? What data did they obtain and what processes
did they do to establish these claims?
The facebook post did not mention
where they found this article or where they got their information. It only had
the authors. I knew I had to find the article for my blog, so I started my
search at the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign library resources that
are available online. I typed in the first author’s last name and caffeine as
keywords and fortunately it was in their database. The article was published on
March 2012 and it is titled,
CAFFEINE WITHDRAWAL AND HIGH-INTENSITY ENDURANCE CYCLING PERFORMANCE
by Christopher Irwin et al. After
glancing over the abstract supplied by the authors I knew this had to be the
article that was mentioned on my facebook home wall. I thoroughly enjoy spending my time at coffee
shops, specifically Starbucks because I am a Gold Member. I am actually
currently at one while writing this blog because here I am prevented from all
distractions, can turn on some Bon Iver, get in my study zone, and of course
drink some iced coffee. I feel very at home here and reading more about the
article enhances my experience here. A combination of all these factors:
facebook, caffeine, starbucks, and my personal life all helped me determine to
write this blog based on this article.
Here's a 3D model of the caffeine molecule:
Here's a 3D model of the caffeine molecule:
The abstract indicated that the
twelve men had to abstain from all forms of caffeine for four days before the
experiment began and then also had to abstain from ingesting any kinds of
caffeine while the study was being taken place. The study contained a
double-blind placebo controlled design where they take one capsule in the
morning and another in the afternoon. So the participants were taking either a
placebo-placebo, placebo-caffeine, caffeine-placebo, or caffeine-caffeine. At
the start of the study they had their participants take some preliminary tests.
The tests were to confirm the participants’ maximal exercise capacity. All of
the participants underwent an incremental test until they were completely
exhausted of energy. This is a peak VO2 test, which means “the maximum amount
of oxygen that an individual can utilize during an intense workout”. This was
done on an electromagnetically braked cycle ergometer to determine peak oxygen
consumption and peak sustainable power output.
After these preliminary tests the participants took their capsules
ninety minutes before taking a time trial that was supposed to be done at
seventy-five percent efficiency. It was found that performance time was
significantly improved after acute caffeine ingestion following a withdrawal
from caffeine period. Here are the findings:
As you can tell by the data, the
caffeine-caffeine group had faster workouts, a greater average power output, an
increase in average heart rate, and their rating of their perceived exertion
was exactly the same as compared to the other three groups. This set of data
supports their hypothesis of after having caffeine withdrawal for four days
then taking caffeine supplements can enhance your work outs by about two
minutes. And to a competitive runner or cyclist those two minutes could mean
everything in a race. I know personally I have come within reach of catching
people in front of me, only to come up short on energy. After reading this
article I am going to start incorporating more caffeine supplements before
competitions.
From that article I wanted to know more about the device they used to record and determine the cyclist VO2 max. I am no engineer or computer person, so these types of machines are a mystery to me and hold a certain form of fascination as well. Throughout my middle school, high school, and some of my college career I have been a runner and I have done numerous VO2 max workouts. I knew the benefit of a VO2 max workout, but not how I could record and measure it. So I decided to do a simple Google search and hoped that something informational and professional would be found. After sifting through some of the hits on Google, I came across a study done by Rehabilitation Clinical Center, Los Angeles Biomedical Research Institute. In it they gave a description of what the machine is. Here is a sample photo:
I also wanted to learn a bit more about VO2 max. It turns out that VO2 is divided into supply and demand factors. The supply portion is the transport of oxygen from the lungs to the mitochondria. The demand portion, on the other hand, is the rate at which the mitochondria can reduce oxygen in the process of oxidative phosphorylation. Oxidative phosphorylation is a metabolic pathway the captures the energy released from nutrients that are oxidized and produce adenosine triphosphate (ATP).
Upon completing this research I
have a better understanding of the benefits of caffeine supplements for work
outs, the machinery that was used to determine VO2 max, and the process of VO2
max in the body. I am definitely no professional or expert by any means on
these topics covered, but instead I hope you now understand the benefits of the
boundless thicket because it is a wealth of information covering varying
topics. Some interesting things I came across while doing my research was that
there were other articles on caffeine usage for competitions. One of the
articles was a debate on caffeine doping before races and that it should be
tested! This is crazy to me because caffeine can come in many sources and
should not be restricted. Through all this complaining, we may see the creation
of a planned diet created by a committee that you can only eat if you wish to
compete in elite competitions like the Olympics. Another interesting article I
found was about taking caffeine supplements before a shot put competition and
in that study it was also found that caffeine can enhance your performance if
taken about sixty minutes before your throws occur. This intrigues me because
caffeine use can then expand beyond running work outs which uses continuous
muscle usage, and then it can also be used for short bursts of energy.
For any additional information
please review the list of resources at the bottom.
Caffeine Withdrawal and High-Intensity Endurance Cycling Performance from Journal of Sports Sciences March 2011
VO2 Max Testing Sit
Caffeine Withdrawal and High-Intensity Endurance Cycling Performance from Journal of Sports Sciences March 2011
VO2 Max Testing Sit
Tyler, your blog was very interesting and surely many coffee consumers would love to read it. However, I wonder how much caffeine was in the capsules that the participants from the study mentioned consumed? Was it significantly high or would you see the same results by just drinking 1 or 2 cups of coffee? Also, I think that many people would like to see if drinking so much caffeine is associated with any side effects. WOuld have been great if you could have provided a study or so showing the effects of caffeine on our body. I guess your blog would have been too long then. However, over all great results!
ReplyDeleteI loved the drawings in this post and I am sure the topic is one that is near to hearts of all undergrads. I would be curious to find out the mg percent of caffeine that the pills contained to get a sense of relevance to results that were published. You mention at the end that throwers take pills for better results. I find myself at all loss to appreciate how caffeine and its relationship with short term energy bursts as the study shown was for power over an average of time. So that topic would be worth looking into. Overall it was a well put together post and I enjoyed the conclusion.
ReplyDeleteTyler, thank you for the interesting topic. I am a regular coffee drinker and also a runner. This was very beneficial to me in terms of daily activities. I had no idea that caffeine had such impact on our exercise performance. When there is days that I don't drink coffee my metabolism slows down and I became very lazy. I think coffee helps us in performing better but I am scared if there is any side effect to consuming such amounts of caffeine. Also, in one article that I read on yahoo, it said that caffeine helps us in reducing our daily stress. Do you think that being less stressed also has an impact on how well you perform while exercising. I think I see a relationship here. This would be a new topic to search, though. But overall very well done!
ReplyDeleteThis article captured my attention because I also enjoy coffee and often use it to boost my exercise performance. I was a bit confused on your analysis of the main study you looked at though. From my perspective, it looked like caffeine had a small, possibly negligible (statistically insignificant)effect on the exercise performance. And I was under the impression that the time of the workout was measuring when they actually were too exhausted to continue (since it was a VO2 max test), which would mean caffeine negatively impacts performance. But I could be wrong in this analysis. I particularly enjoyed your concluding paragraph. You brought up a lot of interesting points/ideas that I had never thought of. For instance, if caffeine is a performance enhancer, then where can officials of events draw the line as to what is legal and what isn't? And how could future research affect this view of caffeine? Anyway, very thought provoking article indeed.
ReplyDelete